COALITION AGAINST INSTITUTIONALIZED CHILD ABUSE
HEADLINE NEWS                                                                                                                                                                                                             CAICA EN FRANÇAIS
 

CAICA     HOME   │   NEWS    PROGRAM NEWS   STORIES  DEATHS  │   WWASPS   │  PARENTS' CORNER  │  MISSION   SITE MAP   LINKS & RESOURCES
 _______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

              AUTISM  │ LITIGATION  │  LEGISLATION  JUVENILE JUSTICE  MENTAL HEALTH LIGHTER SIDE   EN FRANCAIS  COMMENTS  │ LIST SERVE  │  BLOGS  
 

 

THE MILITARY ACADEMY
12.01.07
by Sophie des Deserts for Le Nouvel Observateur.

THE MILITARY ACADEMY

SEGO ( 1 ) WAS DREAMING OF IT. MAM ( 2) DID IT. SECOND CHANCE RESIDENCES FOR
ADOLESCENTS WITH DIFFICULTIES. WITH MILITARY TEACHERS. THEIR SLOGAN, YES,
CHIEF, YES, CHIEF.
 


The French flag floats in the mist. " Allons enfants de la patrie ..." ( 3 ) starts singing the lieutenant-colonel. A hundred 
youngsters, perfectly dressed in black parkas, stand in line in front of him: straight hair, frizzy hair, shaved heads, 
fragile girls and healthy guys. A French bataillon which is composed of blacks, whites and Arabs whose eyes are 
really tired. It's 8 a.m, the air is freezing. After the hot cocoa, " La Marseillaise " ( 4 ) doesn't go down well. People 
whisper in the rows: " Louder ". The little soldiers hold their head up and start singing again. No hesitation until the end.
The chief observes, looking satisfied: " Attention ". A crow passes by, a long silence: " At ease. And have a nice 
day."

We rub our eyes, pinch ourselves, wonder if we're shooting a documentary about the national military service, in 
this beautiful Montry castle which belonged to the baron de Reilhac...No, it's here, just near Euro Disney, that the state 
is experimenting its new idea to save the youth: the " centre Défense seconde chance " ( = the " second chance Defense 
centre " ). A military camp meant to make people feel enthusiastic about working...Ségolène was dreaming of it, MAM did 
it. Little savages ( 5 ), those without qualifications and all those 18 years old without any diplomas and energy left are 
warned. The army recruits during the days the Department of Defence trains the youth ( 6 ). 6 months in a boarding 
school, a period renewable 3 times, the youngsters are fully taken care of and even paid 300 euros per month and 160 
euros when the contract has expired. The experience is tempting...Some even think it's a challenge. " It's Koh Lanta 
( 7 ) " , jokes a group of friends recruited last June. " And we were told we'd have a real job, a flat and even our driving 
license..." They sign the contract.

Parents are relieved, children are often happy to leave. " Most of our youngsters come from weakened families, the 
parents are divorced, unemployed, single mothers " sighs Joel Dehove, the centre's head, a former lieutenant-colonel who
 can sing " La Marseillaise " so well. " They find a second chance here." The man looks calm and his voice is firm. He talks 
to the young volunteers as if he was talking about sending his men to Kosovo: " Come on, guys, we'll get you out of 
here." Aurore, aged 18, a blonde girl with big sad eyes, smiles. Her mother stays at home, her father is a cleaner, she didn't 
have the courage to continue her horticulture course. " My parents told me: " Go, it's your last chance to find a job." 
Jérôme, aged 21, from Nanterre: " Same for me. I was going round in circles between my mates and my video games." 
Laura, aged 19, is a rebel with beautiful white skin: " I didn't get up anymore, my mother was screaming at me, I didn't 
listen. I needed discipline." According to Johan, Montry is simply " the last chance." Too much time wasted, too much 
stupid things in the housing project. The little West Indian from Colombes confesses, speaking as fast as a submachine gun .
" I'm holding on. But it's tough. Look at the way we're dressed! "

Everyone must be dressed like a mechanic and wear big military boots. Equality starts here, by throwing your Converse 
shoes in a cupboard. The army supplies everything, including the shower gel and sports shoes for the 2 daily hours of sport...
" They want to change us " whispers a big fellow from the area nr 93 in Paris ( 8 ). Piercing as well as tattoos, make up and 
long hair are forbidden...Boys and girls are asked not to go too near to each other. " We first work on behavior, explains Joel 
Dehove. The problem with these youngsters is that they don't obey rules anymore. Companies tell us: if you teach them 
how to behave and to accept authority, we can make something out of them." According to the colonel, the 4 first months 
at the centre are crucial. It's a phase of assessment, training and careers advice. The day starts at 6 a.m, time to get 
washed, to tidy up, to raise the flag, to go for a walk around the park...The lazy ones are condemned to community 
service such as cleaning the gymnasium or the paths. " We quickly understand we must obey ", says a skinny dark-haired 
Algerian girl. Those who work in the centre, mostly former military professionals and a few special needs teachers, don't let 
them go. They know everything. Supervise everything. Repeat 10 to 20 times a day : your hands out of your pockets, hold 
your shoulder straight, forget about slang..." " They think we're poodles ", grumbles a little dark-haired boy. His mate: They 
want to change our behaviour as if we were riffraff ( 9 ) ." Others obey without complaining. " They repeat I must stop 
smiling in a silly way ", sniggers a young girl with a bun in her hair from Neuilly-sur-Marne. Nesrine doesn't complain about 
anything, neither about the pumps sessions nor about the evenings without T.V, but she finds the " classes rather light ". 
A few hours of computer classes, of math and French are first of all meant to teach the basics to those who haven't 
learned them...This morning, the lesson consists of writing a letter to introduce oneself. Hadama, drowned in his outfit, 
leans hard on his pen. " So, I heard of a school for those who failed at school. I come from Senegal, I stopped school at
11." Beside him, a big blond boy falls asleep on his folder. He managed to write : " I have a wide experience of schools. I'm 
not good at math and English." The young French teacher hired by the Department of Education kindly advises him to 
emphasize the positive aspects. Someone raises his hand at the back of the class : " I've made mistakes during my youth 
that enabled me to become mature..." The teacher smiles tenderly: " Most of them have dropped out of school at 12 or 
14, a very small minority is illiterate. Here, in a group of 10 or 12, we can teach the basics again."

Behind the window, small groups walk in time singing as if they were in the legion : " We've been walking for 3 days..." 
Some are going to a first aid lesson, others to play basketball. The " alpha section " attends a civics lesson. They're taught 
that " smoking is bad for your heart, lungs and...neurons. It can lead to understanding difficulties, teaches a former 
police officer. Have  you understood, kids? " At the second chance centre, people are blunt, they focus on what's essential: 
what's the purpose of a national health service card  ( 10 ) , of a passport, of a pay slip. They learn about the Général de 
Gaulle's life but most of all how to read the contents of a bag of concrete or an extinguisher's instructions for use. 
After 4 months of disciplined lessons about life, volunteers must be able to choose a career. The old dreams during which 
one wished to become a stylist, a singer or a cosmonaut are over...Back to Earth. " Our youngsters left school years ago, 
insists Denis Oubre, a former Air Force member, who's in charge of the training. We tell them the truth. We suggest they 
choose a career in prosperous markets that are recruiting staff: building and public works sector, catering, logistics, 
security and gardening..." They start with a first training course, then, if everything goes well, another one. The Montry 
centre only has 2 training courses to offer in the very centre, in order to become a watchman and to obtain a gardening
vocational training certificate. Aurore wishes to try this. This afternoon, the sad looking girl clears up the park's leaves. 
Johan, the small tough guy from Colombes who dreams of becoming a special needs teacher, has applied for a logistics ' 
training course, " logistics ", a nice word he says. In a few weeks, if everything goes well, he'll be filling up cardboard 
boxes in a warehouse. Laura, the rebel, did a 3 months long catering training course. Still not convinced, she wants to 
work in a kindergarten. Impossible, replied the training course's director : " No employment here." However, she managed to 
find a 2 months long training course in a youth centre...Here, the youngsters are repeated every day that they must remain 
focused, put up with the constraints in order to have a better future, but that there's still a long way to go...

Depression in the evening as the lights go off. Still 3 days to go before being liberated for the weekend. And as weeks go 
by, the group of friends decreases. Thefts, small marijuana traffics, being late, insolent...some are expelled. Others slam 
the door. The head says 30 % go. According to the volunteers, they'd actually be much more. Marie - Cécile, one of the very 
first to be recruited, held on 4 months. " Getting up at 6 a.m to do nothing apart from cleaning the estate, doing military 
marches, staying to study when you don't have any homework. I don't see the point." Adamé clenched her teeth until 
the 6 months were over in order to obtain a small salary. She's 19, her parents are Malian, she has a Sioux's look, this 
former volunteer has a bitter memory of her stay at Montry. Adamé however represented the school 10 times in front of 
journalists, company heads, and even this summer at garden party at the Elysée palace ( 11 ). " Everyone congratulated us 
but, after spending 6 months there, I was still at square one. Phoney training, phoney training course, I have the feeling 
they lock us up here in order to make the unemployment rate's statistics decrease." Other volunteers, fortunately, make 
them really go down. After one hard year, 3 training course in a company, Fabien, a Haitian boy, has obtained a vocational 
training certificate which focused on maintaining buildings, and found a job at la Défense ( 12 ). The mother who's still got 
5 children to bring up is glad. " He hated studying. He's changed. Learning a job in a military way is a very good idea."

A 24000 EUROS REHABILITATION

Launched in September 2005 by Michèle Alliot-Marie, the Department of defence minister, operation second chance was first 
aimed at 20 000 youngsters. Since the first boarding school opened in Montry, 10 centers have been created all over France. 
But, until now, about 1000 youngsters have been enlisted. " The first years give really encouraging results " announces
Nathalie Mouillet, the communication manager at l' Epide, the organization chosen by the Department of Defence to develop 
the project. " About 60 % of the volunteers would have found, once their training course was over, an apprenticeship contract,
a training course, a fixed-term contact or a permanent contract." Cost, financed by the social cohesion plan: 24 000 euros per
volunteer and per year.

TRANSLATOR'S EXTRA INFORMATION:

I've chosen to select certain facts in this article so that readers who're not from France understand this article better.

( 1 ) Ségolène Royal was previously the Department of Education's minister. She's currently running for president. She comes 
from a military family.

( 2 ) Michèle Alliot-Marie is currently  the Department of Defence minister.

( 3 ) " Allons enfants de la patrie " are the first words of La Marseillaise, France's national anthem.

( 4 ) La Marseillaise is France's national anthem.

( 5 ) The French version uses the expression " sauvageons " meaning " little savages " deliberately. Jean-Pierre Chevénement, 
former Department of the Interior minister, caused a national outcry when he called poor youngsters " little savages " in the 80's.

( 6 ) The national military service is not compulsory anymore. Instead, all young men must attend a special day's training. The 
army makes the most of it to try and recruit people.

( 7 ) Koh Lanta's a famous TV show which is set in heavenly surroundings.

( 8 ) The part of Paris between Nanterre and Bobigny which number is 93 is notorious for its poverty, violent schools and 
poor results.

( 9 ) Nicolas Sarkozy, currently the Department of Interior minister and who's running for president, caused a national outcry 
when he called some youngsters " racaille " meaning riffraff.

( 10 ) In French, this card is called " carte Vitale."

( 11 ) L'Elysée is the palace located in the centre of Paris and is the president's official home.

( 12 ) La Défense is a famous business district in Paris.
__________________________________________ 
TRANSLATOR'S NOTE: In France, boot camps or behavior modification programs such as WWASP's don't exist. 
Instead, the government has gradually decided to open some " centres d'éducation fermés " ( = closed educational 
centres ) in order to rehabilitate persistent young offenders. Those schools are located in remote areas in the 
countryside. There are now 22 in France. Their opening is still very controversial. Nevertheless, several candidates 
who are currently running for president have emphasized there should be more of them. The article, New Closed Educational
Centre Opens in Gévézé, talks about one of these centers which opened in Gévézé, just outside of Rennes, the capital 
of Brittany, where I live. I read this article in the most famous local newspaper, Ouest-France. Gévézé is in the middle of 
the countryside. The center can welcome up to 12 youngsters who're between 13 and 16 years old. It's the 22nd centre
in France. It's financed by the Department of Justice and managed by a Spanish association called Diagrama. Diagrama 
already deals with more than 20 other centers in Spain.

Article translated by Anne-Marie Barré, Rennes, France

 

 

DISCLAIMER, WARNINGS, AND NOTICE TO READERS: This website does not represent or endorse the accuracy or reliability of any of the information, content collectively, the "Materials") contained on, distributed through, or linked, downloaded or accessed from any of the services contained on this website (the "Service"). None of the contributors, sponsors, administrators or anyone else connected with this website in any way whatsoever can be responsible for the appearance of any inaccurate or libelous information or for your use of the information contained in these web pages. All information provided using this website is only intended to be general summary information to the public.

FAIR USE NOTICE: These pages may contain copyrighted (© ) material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Such material is made available to advance understanding of ecological, political, human rights, economic, democracy, scientific, moral, ethical, and social justice issues, etc. It is believed that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, this material is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior general interest in receiving similar information for research and educational purposes. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml. If you wish to use copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

REFERRALS: CAICA is not a referral agency. CAICA does not refer to or promote facilities or transport companies for children or teens. CAICA warns parents that the parent pay / parent choice programs ie. Residential Treatment Centers, Therapeutic Boarding Schools, Behavior Modification Programs, Christian Programs, Positive Peer Culture Programs, etc., are not regulated by the Federal Government and that it is a "Buyer Beware" industry. CAICA provides the following for parents: Message to Parents, Help for Distraught and Desperate Parents, and Questions to Ask and Warning Signs.

© 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008